Payment Options

Consumers Insurance makes it easy to pay your premium by providing a policyholder portal. Click below to be taken to the Consumers Insurance website to log in.

One-Time Payment

One-time payments for personal insurance policies and commercial insurance policies can be made with a credit card, debit card, or checking account. Commercial lines insurance policy down payments are also accepted.

Recurring Payment

You can have your premium payment automatically applied to your checking account or credit card. ATM/debit cards are not accepted at this time. Through our online service you can enroll in recurring payments as well as update credit card information.

888-729-8555

Use our automated system anytime to make a payment over the phone using your credit card, debit card or checking account.

Pay by Mail

Mail your payment to the following address. Make checks payable to Consumers Insurance.

Consumers Insurance
P.O. Box 182155 
Columbus, OH 43218