Consumers Insurance Pay Bill

We make it easy to pay your premium online. Click the one-time payment button below to log in.

One-time payments for personal insurance policies and commercial insurance policies can be made with a credit card, debit card, or checking account. Commercial lines insurance policy down payments are also accepted.

One-time Payment

Use our automated system anytime to make a payment over the phone using your credit card, debit card or checking account.

888-729-8555

Mail your payment to the following address. Make checks payable to Consumers Insurance.

Consumers Insurance
P.O. Box 182155
Columbus, Ohio 43218